| BK | Survivor (1) | Drunken Beer Bums (3) | SuperCrew (5) | The Captains (6) | D Town Blue Drinkers (9) | Melyssa Ford's Fans (11) | |||||||
| 1 | LaDainian Tomlinson | Priest Holmes | Ahmad Green | > | Clinton Portis | Deuce McAllister | Shaun Alexander | ||||||
| 2 | Hines Ward | Chad Johnson | Cory Dillon | < | Daunte Culpepper | Stephen Davis | Peyton Manning | ||||||
| 3 | Kevin Jones ® | Travis Henry | Santana Moss | > | Tiki Barber | Joe Horn | Darrell Jackson | ||||||
| 4 | Amani Toomer | Peerless Price | Steve Smith | < | Chris Chambers | Charles Rogers | Lee Suggs | ||||||
| 5 | Thomas Jones | Todd Heap | Steve McNair | > | Koren Robison | Jimmy Smith | Andre Johnson | ||||||
| 6 | Alge Crumpler | Travis Minor | Quentin Griffin | < | Julius Jones | Brett Favre | Kellen Winslow ® | ||||||
| 7 | Eddie George | Chad Pennington | Rod Smith | > | Randy McMicheal | Tyrone Wheatley | Willis McGahee | ||||||
| 8 | Tom Brady | Robert Ferguson | Joey Galloway | < | Eddie Kennison | Boo Williams | Roy Williams ® | ||||||
| 9 | Deion Branch | New England | Freddie Jones | > | Miami | Peter Warrick | Buffalo | ||||||
| 10 | Josh Reed | Johnnie Morton | Tatum Bell ® | < | Dennis Nothcutt | Jeff Garcia | Keenan McCardell | ||||||
| 11 | Jake Plumber | Mike Vanderjagt | Brad Johnson | > | Jeff Wilkins | Jason Elam | Bubba Franks | ||||||
| 12 | Drew Bennett | Tommy Madox | Donald Driver | < | Mark Brunnell | Justin Fargas | David Carr | ||||||
| 13 | St. Louis | Marcus Robinson | Chris Perry ® | > | Ike Hilliard | David Givens | David Akers | ||||||
| 14 | Jerome Pathon | Artose Pinner | Brandon Lloyd | < | Troy Brown | Tampa Bay | Jabar Gaffney | ||||||
| 15 | Tennessee | Larry Johnson | Dallas | > | Antowain Smith | Richie Anderson | Terry Glenn | ||||||
| 16 | Joe Nedney | Kelly Washington | John Carney | < | Ladell Betts | Reno Mahe | Washington | ||||||
| 17 | Mike Anderson | Ricky Williams MIA | Jason Witten | > | Itula Mili | Jim Kleinsasser | Jay Feely | ||||||
| 18 | Billy Miller | Kyle Brady | Garrison Hearst | < | Green Bay | Atlanta | James Stewart | ||||||
| Squad 420 (10) | Slayers (8) | Padan Fain (12) | Emperor of Beers (4) | Madden's Mayhem (7) | 9 Angry Monkeys (2) | ||||||||
| 1 | Jamal Lewis | Edgerrin James | Marshall Faulk | > | Randy Moss | Marvin Harrison | Fred Taylor | ||||||
| 2 | Michael Bennett | Torry Holt | Terrell Owens | < | Rudi Johnson | Kevin Barlow | Domanick Davis | ||||||
| 3 | Michael Vick | Brian Westbrook | Chris Brown | > | Duce Staley | Matt Hasselbeck | Donovan McNabb | ||||||
| 4 | Derrick Mason | Eric Moulds | Tony Gonzalez | < | Curtis Martin | Charlie Gardner | Laveranues Coles | ||||||
| 5 | T.J. Duckett | Jeremy Shockey | Trent Green | > | Javon Walker | Ashley Lelie | Plaxico Burress | ||||||
| 6 | Jerry Porter | Aaron Brooks | Isaac Bruce | < | Marc Bulger | Marty Booker | Warrick Dunn | ||||||
| 7 | Donte' Stallworth | Marcel Shipp | Larry Fitzgerald ® | > | DeShaun Foster | Andre' Davis | Keyshawn Johnson | ||||||
| 8 | Anquan Boldin | Justin McCareins | Baltimore | < | Reggie Wayne | Jerome Bettis | Steven Jackson | ||||||
| 9 | Philadelphia | Detroit | Anthony Thomas | > | Quincy Morgan | Lee Evans ® | Emmitt Smith | ||||||
| 10 | L.J. Smith | Muhsin Muhammad | William Green | < | Rod Gardner | Moe Williams | Jerry Rice | ||||||
| 11 | Eli Manning ® | Adam Vinatieri | Ryan Longwell | > | David Terrell | Mike Alstott | Drew Bledsoe | ||||||
| 12 | Daniel Graham | Jake Delhomme | Byron Leftwidh | < | Joey Harrington | Greg Jones | Marcus Pollard | ||||||
| 13 | Jason Hanson | Antonio Bryant | Todd Pinkston | > | Antonio Gates | Kevin Johnson | John Kasay | ||||||
| 14 | Justin Gage | Erron Kinney | Reggie Williams ® | < | Carolina | Seattle | Tony Hollings | ||||||
| 15 | Martin Gramatica | Pittsburgh Steelers | LaMont Jordan | > | Najeh Davenport | Dallas Clark | Kansas City | ||||||
| 16 | Reche Caldwell | Curtis Conway | Onterrio Smith | < | Chester Taylor | New Orleans | Ron Dayne | ||||||
| 17 | Michael Clayton ® | Sebastian Janikowski | Bobby Engram | > | Dominic Rhodes | Carson Palmer | Desmond Clark | ||||||
| 18 | Jamal Robertson | Michael Pittman | Jacksonville | < | Matt Stover | Josh Brown | Denver | ||||||